Insurance coverage CEO wage: How a lot do executives of the highest insurers earn?

The CEOs of the nation’s largest insurance coverage corporations rake in hundreds of thousands of {dollars} annually as a part of their jobs of main their companies to profitability. However how a lot do these executives make precisely?

Insurance coverage Enterprise crunches the numbers from the earlier monetary years to offer you an concept of how a lot the highest insurance coverage CEOs earn in salaries and different compensation. We may also make a side-by-side comparability to seek out out the place their earnings rank amongst their business friends.

In the event you’re questioning how a lot the business’s high executives make and whether or not they’re deserving of the pay, you’ve come to the suitable place. Achieve a deeper understanding of the numbers behind insurance coverage CEO wage and compensation on this information.

The desk beneath from the patron advocacy and schooling non-profit breaks down the whole pay of the chief executives of those corporations within the final two monetary years. The group obtained the information from the Nebraska Division of Insurance coverage. The division legally requires insurers to supply details about the salaries, bonuses, and different compensation of their high officers. 

Insurance coverage Enterprise rearranged the record from the best to the bottom incomes CEO in 2022.

Insurance coverage CEO compensation – private strains insurers

The record is break up evenly between the CEOs whose pay elevated and people whose compensation dropped. For the latter group, most executives skilled simply marginal decreases in earnings.

On the flipside, Liberty Mutual’s Lengthy and USAA’s Peacock obtained the best pay increase at $3.2 million and $2.9 million, respectively.

CFA famous, nevertheless, that the information reported to the division might exclude compensation paid by affiliated corporations, so it’s potential that the figures above are underrepresented.

Insurance coverage CEO compensation – P&C, multiline insurers

The group’s record additionally doesn’t embrace insurance coverage CEO wage and compensation for the nation’s high multiline insurers and medical insurance specialists, a few of that are considerably greater than these within the desk.

The desk beneath reveals the 10 highest-paid CEOs of the nation’s high P&C and multiline insurers, in keeping with knowledge obtained by the market intelligence agency S&P World.  

AIG’s Peter Zaffino has the best compensation amongst all insurance coverage CEOs on the record, incomes 894 instances extra in comparison with that of the agency’s common worker. Hagerty of his household’s eponymous firm and Chubb’s Greenburg spherical up the highest three. Greenburg made 346 instances greater than Chubb’s common employee. 

Insurance coverage CEO compensation – well being insurers

The CEOs of the six largest medical insurance corporations within the US earned a mixed $114.5 million in salaries and different compensation in 2022. That is in keeping with the Securities and Trade Fee (SEC) proxy filings obtained by the business information outlet Fierce Healthcare. Right here’s the record organized from the best to the bottom earners. 

There’s just a little bit extra parity within the pay of the CEOs of the high medical insurance corporations within the US. The figures above present that the salaries and compensation of the highest 4 executives are separated by a couple of hundred thousand {dollars}. Their earnings, nevertheless, are between 270 and 380 instances greater than these of their corporations’ common staff.   

Similar to common staff, the chief executives of insurance coverage corporations get an annual wage. They’re additionally entitled to worker advantages corresponding to paid holidays and group insurance coverage. Nonetheless, CEO compensation is extra difficult and includes a spread of different components that transcend simply their reported salaries and advantages.

Amongst these components are efficiency rewards. Insurance coverage CEOs usually earn bonuses relying on the corporate’s general efficiency, progress, and profitability, in addition to shareholder worth. For this reason CEO compensation is typically described as “pay-for-performance.”

Right here’s a listing of the frequent parts that go right into a CEO compensation package deal:

Base wage

Most insurance coverage CEOs earn substantial base salaries, which rely upon a spread of things, together with job efficiency and years of expertise. An govt compensation committee shaped by the board of administrators sometimes units the annual determine. The CEO then will get paid in money both month-to-month or biweekly. 

Efficiency-based incentives

Efficiency-based incentives kind a major a part of insurance coverage CEO compensation. These can come within the type of short-term rewards for reaching sure revenue- or operation-based targets. They can be long-term incentives that target targets that may be achieved in additional than a yr.

Brief-term incentives are sometimes given as money rewards, whereas long-term incentives are sometimes structured as stock-based compensation. CEOs normally obtain compensation for long-term incentives on the finish of their acknowledged efficiency intervals.

Worker advantages

Similar to salaried employees, insurance coverage CEOs are entitled to a number of worker advantages, together with:

• Social Safety
• Paid trip and holidays
• Extra day off for sick pay or private sabbaticals
• Staff’ compensation
• Medical health insurance
• Medicare
• Life insurance coverage
• Unemployment insurance coverage
• Retirement plans

CEO perks

CEOs can entry further advantages that aren’t obtainable to different salaried staff, together with:

• Employed drivers
• Particular parking privileges
• Safety at dwelling or work
• Communications techniques of their dwelling
• Entry to personal planes

These perks are designed to compensate CEOs for the additional calls for on their time. 

Severance package deal

Insurance coverage corporations present CEOs with severance pay within the occasion of voluntary or involuntary termination. Some packages embrace a change-in-control provision, additionally known as a “golden parachute.” This compensates chief executives in the event that they lose their jobs due to a merger or an acquisition the place the buying entity replaces them with their very own leaders.

CEOs play an important position within the success or failure of an organization, which makes their roles essential. Nonetheless, there’s nonetheless an ongoing debate on whether or not they deserve the compensation they obtain.

Michael DeLong, analysis and advocacy affiliate on the Shopper Federation of America, says the group understands the necessity for insurance coverage corporations to supply aggressive salaries to draw proficient leaders. The group’s concern, nevertheless, is how insurers acquire the funds to compensate their senior executives.

“Whereas we predict that present insurance coverage CEO salaries are grossly extreme and undeserved, we’re centered on the truth that these inflated salaries are usually paid by insurance coverage firm policyholders and never the shareholders,” he explains. “These huge salaries and bonuses got here throughout a time when auto insurance coverage charges rose, and the insurance coverage corporations claimed they needed to increase charges with a view to cowl rising prices.

“The insurers additionally claimed they have been in monetary bother resulting from a wide range of components, so that they wanted to chop prices. They slashed promoting, elevated premiums for odd individuals, and in some instances shut down buildings and laid off a few of their staff. Nonetheless, the insurance coverage corporations didn’t reduce their CEO compensation in any respect. In actual fact, insurance coverage CEOs are incomes dramatically extra now than they did previous to the pandemic.”

DeLong provides that the state of affairs has bolstered the general public’s detrimental notion of excessive insurance coverage CEO salaries.

“CEO salaries are extraordinarily excessive, usually within the hundreds of thousands or tens of hundreds of thousands of {dollars}, and they’re unconnected to efficiency,” he says. “On the identical time, many Individuals live paycheck to paycheck and struggling to afford their insurance coverage premiums.

“The issue with the mismatch between enormous CEO compensation packages and the monetary struggles of American customers is especially acute in insurance coverage, since state legal guidelines require that we buy insurance coverage. Since we’re compelled to purchase their merchandise, it makes individuals very indignant to be taught that their excessive premium is, partly, protecting the multi-million-dollar payday of the corporate executives.”

DeLong additionally calls on the insurance coverage regulators to do their half in addressing the difficulty.

“Besides in California, the place shopper safety guidelines restrict the quantity of govt wage that may be handed alongside to policyholders, insurance coverage regulators usually enable the prices of govt salaries to be constructed into the charges they cost their prospects,” he notes.

“We wish to see regulators step in and defend customers from having to bear the burden of wildly inflated govt salaries and bonuses.”

The SEC requires all publicly traded corporations, together with insurers, to reveal how a lot they pay their senior executives, how they decide the general compensation, and who helped set the whole package deal. This implies you will get data on insurance coverage CEO salaries via public filings with the SEC.

As well as, you’ll find knowledge on CEO compensation in different paperwork, together with:

• The insurer’s annual proxy assertion
• Type 10-Okay or the insurer’s annual report
• Registration paperwork

It’s also possible to preserve abreast of the most recent business developments, together with senior management actions and salaries, by subscribing to our free newsletters. By signing up, you’ll be updated with the most recent breaking information, cutting-edge opinion, and skilled evaluation impacting the business.

What’s your opinion in regards to the wage and compensation of CEOs within the insurance coverage business? Do you suppose it’s honest? Share your feedback beneath.